Maria Bustillos on Tokenizing Journalism, the Death of Civil and Rise of Brick House

Maria Bustillos, founding editor of the digital magazine Popula, is furthermore one amongst the founding members of Brick Condominium, an umbrella of self sustaining publishers working beneath a collectivist business mannequin. 

An earlier supporter, and benefactor, of the now-defunct media startup Civil, Bustillos talked about she beneath no cases lost witness of the chance of a journalist-owned media firm. 


Brick Condominium will initiating this October with nine sister publications, every of which owns a single fragment within the upper firm. It will indulge in “no owners, no executives, and no merchants,” nor advertisers. 

The collective will enhance itself thru $75 yearly subscriptions, which presents earn entry to to every of the founding publications: including the investigative journal Sludge, podcast FAQ NYC, and a weblog devoted to “peripheral places within the sector on the margins” known as No Man Is an Island. 

Bustillos dialed true into a Zoom name beneath the alias Bluestocking, an stale insult to sigh a “neatly-read” girl. We discussed the fallout from Civil’s closure, Brick Condominium’s non-tokeneconomic business mannequin and the plot in which immutable epic-conserving will live tyrants from chilling speech. 

Is Brick Condominium a reference to The Commodores song?

It has a form of attention-grabbing associations, doesn’t it? I point out essentially. Tom Scocca and I indulge in been talking about the premise of a cooperative and methods to present protection to press freedom, and I had talked about we desire to indulge in a improvement that will presumably well’t be blown down. That’s the effect it started, and we realized later the name works on a different of levels. 

Portion of the improvement of Brick Condominium is that you are going to also don’t indulge in any owners, merchants or executives. Could well perchance presumably you expose me what a journalist-owned media cooperative truly appears love? 

Nicely, most entrepreneurial assignment relies mostly entirely in growing equity. Corporations are essentially equity that is disbursed between other folks that notify possession, with the premise being that at closing it grows in price and could presumably well presumably merely restful be provided. Because of the the persona of journalism – as a public have confidence, reasonably than an entrepreneurial assignment – the premise of saleable equity and an investor/owner improvement is at odds with informing the final public. It’s been essentially adversarial for the profession. 

Brick Condominium’s equity is no longer saleable or transferable. We invented a business improvement that’s held in have confidence for the serve of the total publishers that work within the Brick Condominium. There’s an working settlement for sharing revenues and expenses, but the exact equity – the firm – is no longer saleable. Every publisher has a fraction, none can fetch greater than one [share], and you can not promote it outside the firm – you are going to be in a situation to most efficient promote it encourage to the firm for one buck. 

We created this improvement to live anybody that will presumably well merely desire to arrive in and elevate encourage an eye on, or desire publishers. At its worst, this happens to close down, censor, recordsdata or form publishers. 

When there’s a opposed takeover, there’s an try and accumulate up balloting shares. This has been the case with Sheldon Adleson with the Las Vegas Tribune Journal, the case with Peter Thiel and Gawker, the case with Joe Ricketts – these other folks had encourage an eye on of the business entity that operated the publishing. 

If we can insulate the publishing entity – the firm – from that roughly takeover, that will present a level of safety for press freedom.

Brick House, Maria Bustillos
Brick Condominium
Source: Maria Bustillos

This sounds love the possession improvement of Civil, in that it desired to effect an oasis of media rather then company-urge corporations. Why close you suspect Civil failed? 

Most other folks beneath no cases understood the crypto-economic solutions within the encourage of Civil, and why tokenizing journalism used to be a factual advice. It’s truly somewhat identical to what we’re doing at Brick Condominium. The belief used to be that the token would possibly be the automobile throughout which journalists could presumably well strengthen every diverse’s efforts. That came about thru staking tales, giving pointers, no matter. Using a token that used to be denominated in journalistic assignment, Civil members could presumably well strengthen one one more’s work in a technique that used to be no longer equity-based mostly entirely. 

After the loss of life of Civil, [I realized] the reason ICOs indulge in been fought so arduous by the banking alternate used to be that it used to be stressful these structures. Must you are going to also elevate money outside stale VC or funding banking circles, which that you can presumably minimize them out, so they fought it ferociously. That’s my plot.

I beneath no cases lost the imaginative and prescient of creating a business mannequin whereby journalists can strengthen one one more’s work with out counting on outside entities that indulge in agendas that will at closing battle with our work. 

That’s the story of Gawker. There used to be deepest wealth that would be seized. The exact publisher used to be a technique throughout which you are going to also earn at these journalists. 

There’s been some press about how The Current York Times has become extra of a tech firm than a media firm. What’s the viability of upright working a media firm as a media firm?

What keeps The Current York Times alive is it has a form of huge journalists writing about things other folks desire to search out out about. I don’t train that’s at an close. That is no longer the first time this conversation has came about. Radio used to be alleged to murder the newspapers, so used to be tv, now we leer ‘the loss of life’ of local recordsdata on account of the secure. But we furthermore leer a form of oldsters working to revive and who desire local recordsdata. 

The huge success of Civil to me used to be Chicago Block Club, which has grown and grown. They indulge in been gargantuan neat and commenced off as a nonprofit. They’ve carried out all the pieces factual, and indulge in become a fixture in Chicago that a form of oldsters depend on. It’s a mannequin that will presumably well grow. We haven’t viewed the close of blockchain in journalism. We tried one ability, and one day it could become viable. 

We’ve spoken privately about how one amongst Civil’s deadly flaws used to be its token-economic governance improvement. 

I was beneath no cases a supporter of striking token governance because the first expansive challenge at Civil. I fetch token curated registries indulge in a future, but they’re no longer ready for high time. I participated within the authentic token registry, despite the truth that I beneath no cases entirely joined Civil as a publisher.

Most other folks beneath no cases understood the crypto-economic solutions within the encourage of Civil.

It upright requires a large funding in time to encourage an eye on the total publishers. There indulge in been solutions to  apply and you indulge in been counting on the members to vet other folks that came within the door. And a form of oldsters came within the door. 

There indulge in been a different of considerations with how Civil tried to urge itself. I’m so grateful for Civil, they gave us [Popula] its initiating. Each person had their hearts within the factual space. 

But they confronted a form of regulatory headwinds, on high of the total unheard of problems a startup would face, on high of attempting to begin a publishing platform with many, many diversified entities attempting to pursue diverse objectives. It used to be a perfect experiment, but it completely bit off greater than it could also chunk.

The token curated system will not be any exception. It’s an extremely subtle component to situation and urge, and you’d like other folks that indulge in a form of bandwidth to oversee it. The different of oldsters that participated – and you leer this in case after case of token registries – used to be so little, that they without prolong took encourage an eye on over the challenge. There wasn’t this huge body of authorities love imagined. 

It’s kinda love Prick Denton’s Kinja.

I don’t know what that is. 

Kinja used to be an try and surface citizen journalism alongside traditional editorial assert, by mixing media and social media. It upright wasn’t the case that you had 1,000,000 geniuses accessible waiting to post on Kinja. So they spun their wheels attempting to faucet into the ‘crowd solutions.’ 

Unparalleled things can happen by opening a platform up. But I fetch you desire to grow it from a essentially little seed. It’s doubtless you’ll presumably well’t upright initiating the door and hope it could curate itself. There’s 1,000,000 examples of this, the effect other folks fetch the wisdom of the crew is on the market without prolong. Or no longer it is a must desire to work slowly to grow it love a plant. 

That’s what we’re doing with Brick Condominium. We chose about a publishers which would be identified to me and responsible and fetch within the same ability to back improvement this component, so when we close initiating the doors to extra publishers, we know what we’re doing. 

Speaking of the wisdom of crowds. I spotted that a different of the initiatives in Brick Condominium indulge in arrive over from Civil. Including David Moore’s Sludge and Popula. Many of these initiatives situation up micro-tipping parts old to Civil collapsed, is that this a crowdfunding mechanism Brick Condominium would be having a gape at deploying? 

Nicely, we score ETH micropayments at Popula now. Now we indulge in an ETH-based mostly entirely micro tipping and commenting system. These are experiments that I essentially like. It’s no longer the time for them at Brick Condominium, the least bit. Brick Condominium has no crypto component. 

But Popula is experimenting at a little scale with blockchain archiving and cryptoeconomics. We’re restful committed to that. Anybody who’s attracted to doing it at Brick Condominium is welcome to. We’ll note them what we’ve  purchased, it’s very extinct. Take into accout, all these initiatives indulge in been bootstrapped, none of them started off with gigantic portions of cash. Civil used to be very, very neatly-behaved. But a form of cash went down the tubes within the crypto winter. 

Brick Condominium appears in an identical plot bootstrapped. The Kickstarter campaign is most efficient attempting to construct up $75,000. The effect will these funds be deployed? 

All of that is being decided upfront in our working settlement. All we’re going to total with that money is initiating the websites. We’re attempting to begin from a shoestring with out merchants to note a proof of plot that we can promote to readers. 

For the time being, we essentially can’t promote anything else to the readers. But we’re no longer going to notify, we received’t initiating except we elevate $2 million greenbacks, or ample to pay all these salaries for a 300 and sixty five days. We decided we’re upright going to elevate a gape at to effect a easy model of what we’re talking about – an umbrella of publications – and present it to the market. 

You talked about earlier your belief in blockchain archiving. This appears at odds with a cultural climate the effect speech is chilled either thru company takeovers and an increasing number of the crew. Does your belief within the technology replicate a belief in free speech absolution – that unhealthy or unsavory solutions desire to be protected. 

When other folks discuss the First Amendment they veritably fail to recollect it’s a guarantee by the authorities against jailing its opponents. The sooner manner used to be to upright detention center the opposition. It’s doubtless you’ll presumably well upright shut them up, love what’s occurring in China now, by taking the dissidents and striking them in detention center. 

Brick House, Maria Bustillos
Brick Condominium will initiating with nine publications.
Source: Brick Condominium

The belief of press freedom as a governmental factual is break free asserting the final public commons – the effect other folks fragment solutions in a situation and ambiance of mutual appreciate and begin-mindedness. We leer 1,000,000 considerations with that. 

Most of the nonsense we leer, love with the Harper’s letter, the effect other folks are complaining about being ‘censored’ when essentially they’re being repudiated or condemned. It’s furthermore free speech to particular contempt for listless opinions. I don’t fetch we could presumably well merely restful lose witness of that.

There’s an unheard of line on your CJR column announcing Brick Condominium: I fetch you talked about ‘there’s a sacred factual for folks to particular contempt.’ Is there a tension between the factual to earn things unsuitable and the immutability blockchain affords? 

Have a look at it this suggests, if you happen to lost a libel suit within the days old to the secure, it used to be no longer attainable to enter every library and deal with every newspaper. There’s a balance between what’s cheap and unreasonable. The secure has given other folks love Peter Thiel an outsized skill, potentially, to expunge writing and ideas from public reminiscence. Completely. 

I feel blockchain publishing is a pushback against that. No longer a form of oldsters discuss it, but it completely wishes to be spoken of, when any individual love Peter Thiel wants to shutdown Gawker, if the offending story had already been archived on the Ethereum blockchain and intensely unlikely to expunge, wouldn’t it then indulge in dampened the fervour of any individual to skedaddle after a journalist, vivid in fact already accessible. 

To about a level, archives in libraries, universities and cities are a bulwark against that impulse. In point of fact no longer going to skedaddle away. Historians will accumulate it. Posterity will accumulate it. 

Is there anything else you desire so that it’s essential to add?

We’re seeing the encroachment of entrenched pursuits within the blockchain house. Increasingly extra extra banks are getting concerned, there’s an try by Facebook to begin Libra, there are all these attempts to make utilize of blockchain technology to recreate programs of surveillance. I don’t fetch other folks could presumably well merely restful upright sit by and let this stuff note, or lose witness of the promise of blockchain technology to liberate reasonably than enslave other folks. 

It’s attainable to make utilize of these applied sciences – upright love it’s attainable to make utilize of the secure – to present protection to freedoms reasonably than threaten them. It’s a extremely effective instrument in both directions. 

I desire all americans to enhance the Brick Condominium. Esteem, loads. Come donate money, send the total affluent other folks over. I’m no longer getting affluent off this – I essentially indulge in one fragment love all americans else. But I desire all americans to gape that one more business mannequin for journalism is attainable.


The chief in blockchain recordsdata, CoinDesk is a media outlet that strives for one of the best journalistic standards and abides by a strict situation of editorial policies. CoinDesk is an self sustaining working subsidiary of Digital Foreign money Team, which invests in cryptocurrencies and blockchain startups.

Leave a comment